Nearshoring has emerged as a prominent strategy for companies seeking to optimize their supply chains, reduce costs, and enhance competitiveness. This phenomenon involves relocating production operations closer to the final market, rather than relying on distant countries like China. In this article, we will explore the economic impact of nearshoring on local communities, using Tijuana, Mexico, as a representative case study. We will examine how this strategy affects the local economy, considering the benefits and challenges, and evaluate its economic, social, and environmental impacts.
Definition and Context of Nearshoring
Nearshoring is the practice of moving business operations, particularly in manufacturing and services, to countries near the company's final market. Unlike offshoring, which involves moving operations to distant locations with lower production costs, nearshoring focuses on geographical proximity to leverage benefits such as shorter delivery times, reduced transportation costs, and greater control over the supply chain.
In the current context, marked by disruptions to global supply chains due to the COVID-19 pandemic and trade tensions between the U.S. and China, nearshoring has gained prominence. Mexico, with its proximity to the United States, robust infrastructure, and favorable trade agreements, has become an attractive destination for this strategy.
Benefits and Challenges of Nearshoring
Benefits
Cost Reduction: Nearshoring can significantly reduce transportation and logistics costs, as operations are located closer to the final market.
Supply Chain Improvement: With a shorter supply chain, companies can respond more quickly to changes in demand, improve quality, and reduce risks associated with long distances.
Increased Competitiveness: Companies can benefit from lower labor costs compared to the United States while maintaining high-quality standards.
Strengthening the Local Economy: Foreign direct investment (FDI) can boost local economic development, creating jobs and stimulating other sectors of the economy.
Challenges
Infrastructure: Despite improvements, certain areas may face infrastructure challenges that could limit the efficiency of nearshore operations.
Training and Skilled Labor: The demand for skilled labor may exceed the local supply, requiring training programs and collaboration with educational institutions.
Regulatory and Fiscal Aspects: Companies must navigate the complexities of the regulatory and fiscal environment, which can vary significantly between regions.
Case Study: Tijuana, Mexico
Tijuana has emerged as a strategic hub for nearshoring due to its proximity to California, one of the world's largest economies. The city offers an attractive combination of competitive labor costs, robust infrastructure, and a favorable business environment. Companies from various sectors, such as manufacturing, technology, and services, have established operations in Tijuana to take advantage of these benefits.
The phenomenon of nearshoring has had a significant impact on Tijuana, Baja California, transforming both its industrial real estate market and its economic and social development.
Impact on the Industrial Real Estate Market
Nearshoring has generated unprecedented demand in Tijuana's industrial real estate market. Before the pandemic, the region was already known for its strong presence in sectors such as electronics, home appliances, medical products, and biotechnology. However, the pandemic accelerated industrial diversification, adding industries such as aerospace, information technologies, communications, and medical services. This is reflected in the increase in the number of maquiladora plants, which has risen from fewer than 700 before the pandemic to 956 currently, with 621 of them located in Tijuana.
Economic and Social Development
Nearshoring has positioned Tijuana as a hub of opportunities, attracting significant regional investments. In 2023, more than $700 million were allocated for the construction of new industrial warehouses in the city, surpassing expectations. This dynamism has driven skill development and the improvement of local infrastructure, enriching the social fabric of the city by increasing and diversifying employment opportunities.
Testimonial
A 2023 KPMG report highlighted that 45% of surveyed companies in the United States considered Mexico their preferred destination for nearshoring operations.
Cristina Hermosillo, President of DEITAC: Cristina Hermosillo, President of Tijuana’s Economic and Industrial Development (DEITAC), has highlighted that nearshoring has been a key driver for regional investment. In 2023, more than $700 million were allocated for the construction of new industrial warehouses in Tijuana, surpassing expectations for the period.
Román Caso Espinosa, CEO of Shelter Co-Production International: Román Caso Espinosa has pointed out that nearshoring allows companies to save costs, improve quality controls, and reduce time zone and cultural differences. He also emphasizes that Baja California is well-positioned to benefit from this trend due to its favorable business environment, strategic location, and competent workforce.
Impact on Foxconn: Foxconn, one of the largest contract manufacturing companies, has established operations in Tijuana, highlighting the reduction in operating costs and the improvement in the quality of life for its employees as key factors for its nearshoring decision. The company has invested in infrastructure and employee wellness programs, thereby enhancing productivity and product quality.
Economic, Social, and Environmental Impact
Economic
Nearshoring has had a significant impact on Tijuana's local economy. Foreign direct investment has created thousands of jobs, increasing incomes and improving the living standards of residents. Additionally, it has stimulated other sectors such as construction and services, generating a multiplier effect on the local economy.
Social
From a social perspective, nearshoring has contributed to the development of the local workforce. Collaboration between companies and local universities has resulted in specific training programs, improving workers' skills and competencies. However, rapid expansion has also created challenges in terms of housing and public services, which need to be addressed to maintain sustainable growth.
Environmental
The environmental impact of nearshoring is a critical aspect to consider. Relocating operations can result in a smaller carbon footprint due to reduced transportation distances. However, increased industrial activity can also put pressure on local resources and generate pollution if not managed properly. It is essential for companies to implement sustainable practices and comply with environmental regulations to mitigate these effects.
Future Trends
Nearshoring in Tijuana and other regions of Mexico appears to be on an upward trajectory. Several trends support this outlook:
Digitalization and Automation: The adoption of advanced technologies such as automation and artificial intelligence is transforming nearshore operations, improving efficiency and reducing costs.
Focus on Sustainability: Companies are increasingly committed to sustainable practices, not only to comply with regulations but also to respond to consumer demand for more environmentally friendly products and services.
Diversification of the Industrial Base: Sectors such as technology and services are gaining ground in nearshoring, diversifying the industrial base of regions like Tijuana and creating opportunities for more balanced growth.
Nearshoring represents a significant opportunity for companies seeking to improve their competitiveness and supply chain resilience. Tijuana, with its unique combination of geographical, economic, and social advantages, is an exemplary case study of the benefits and challenges of nearshoring. However, to maximize these benefits, it is crucial to address challenges related to infrastructure, workforce training, and environmental sustainability.
The future of nearshoring in Tijuana and other regions of Mexico looks promising, driven by global trends toward digitalization, sustainability, and industrial diversification. Companies that adopt these practices will not only contribute to local economic development but also enhance their own competitiveness and ability to adapt to a constantly changing global environment.
Ultimately, nearshoring has the potential to transform local economies like Tijuana's, redefining the dynamics of international trade and creating more agile, resilient, and sustainable supply chains.
Comments